Baseball Trading Pins

Our Signature Pins team has been helping coaches and players design custom pins since the year 2000. We know the ins-and-outs of the trading pin world and have all the tools necessary to help you create a custom pin capable of outshining all the competition. The only thing you need to worry about when working with us is whether or not you will be able to part with your

custom trading pin

once you have a chance to hold the final product in your hand.


In stock - Samples are randomized.

Send Us Your Ideas

Download our Design Template

Get an Online Proof

See How to Approve your Artwork

7-10 Day Turnaround

Highest Quality, Fast Production

Trading Pins

Stand Out At Your Next Tournament

Players collect baseball trading pins over the years as they face different teams and travel up and down the countryside. The pins come in all kinds of unique shapes, colors and sizes, and each one tells a different story.

Trading Pin Gallery


Trading Pin Customer Reviews


To Trade or Not To Trade?

This question should be familiar to anyone with a cherished pin collection. Players inevitably find themselves holding a favorite pin and teetering on the verge of trading it away for another design that’s just as good. To trade or not to trade? But these moments and the efforts that go into building a unique collection of pins are what make the experience so much fun.

Baseball team trading pins have come a long way since Little League Baseball introduced their first official trading pin back in 1983, and over the years we’ve seen some incredible custom designs for teams all over the nation. Because they all come in different shapes, sizes and colors, each pin tells a unique story, but they’re all connected by a common love of collecting and trading.

Customizing Your Own Baseball Team Trading Pins

We offer as many custom options as possible for our sports trading pins because we want to make sure our clients have everything they need to bring their vision for design to life. Soft enamel pins have become the go-to style for baseball and softball pins because of their traditional look and feel, with enamel colorfill added to the recessed portions of the design. This creates a two-layer effect that any pin trader will recognize.

If your goal is to create the most sought after baseball trading pin on the field, adding custom options like blinkers, bobbles, danglers, glitter, sliders or spinners is a great place to start. While these are some of our most popular additions for custom baseball and softball trading pins, we have the ability to make any idea work.


Different sports teams find their own ways of incorporating these unique options into their trading pin designs, ensuring that no two pins are ever the same. Whether you need a colorful soft enamel trading pin, a die struck pin with spinners and danglers, or anything else in between, we’ve got you covered.

To get started on your own design, just fill out a free quote form anywhere on our website. All of our customers receive free artwork, free unlimited revisions and free UPS Red Label shipping with their orders. We also take care of the mold and setup fee for pins up to 2” in size and offer up to seven different colors for your design without any extra charge.


Our goal is to provide the best service available and the highest quality products on the market. Our friendly staff, incredible products and honest approach to business have made us the official United States Specialty Sports Association (USSSA) national pin supplier, and we work hard every day to maintain that honor.

Get Started On Your Custom Baseball Trading Pins Today

Trading pins for baseball are the most well known, but our Signature Pins team has experience creating custom pins for all sorts of different sports teams. Custom softball trading pins are popular, as are football, soccer and hockey trading pins. No matter what kind of design you’re looking for, you can be sure our team has what it takes to create a one of a kind pin that’s sure to be a hit with players and fans alike.

Baseball trading pins spinner and blinker

All of the baseball trading pins you see on our website are just examples of what we have created in the past. Every customer receives a brand new design created by our art team, and once artwork is finalized, the custom pins will be on your doorstep within 10 to 12 days. If you’re ready to get started on your own custom baseball trading pin design, give us a call today, and see for yourself why Signature Pins is the best custom lapel pin maker online.

Note: Due to the high volume of trading pins ordered during the months of June and July, some orders may experience increased delivery times. Please consult with your sales representative to determine our current delivery schedule.

Sports Trading Pin Pricing

Size 200 300 400 500 600 750 1,000 1,500 2,000
1.5" $2.38 $1.93 $1.72 $1.43 $1.36 $1.29 $1.22 $1.14 $1.10
1.75" $2.61 $2.12 $1.87 $1.61 $1.53 $1.46 $1.42 $1.24 $1.20
2" $2.80 $2.28 $2.07 $1.83 $1.75 $1.68 $1.64 $1.46 $1.42
2.25" $3.75 $3.26 $2.95 $2.70 $2.62 $2.54 $2.48 $2.30 $2.25
2.5" $4.38 $3.92 $3.61 $3.36 $3.28 $3.20 $3.14 $2.96 $2.91
2.75" $4.90 $4.34 $4.02 $3.76 $3.68 $3.59 $3.51 $3.33 $3.27
3" $5.40 $4.79 $4.47 $4.21 $4.13 $4.04 $3.96 $3.78 $3.72
Oversize mold fee of $75.00 for pins 2.0" and larger

above and beyond other trading pins

Trading Pin Options


A trading pin dangler is a movable part and requires a second mold and design. Typically the dangler is attached via a "ring" but they can also be attached to small jewelry chain. The dangler option is often used to designate tournament details, like the year of the tournament, a baseball, a glove, a softball, the state, and more. Most commonly danglers are used to designate the year of the tournament series.


A spinner is a small second pin joined on to the first which twists and turns. Spinners can come in any shape you can imagine, but the spinner style is important to your overall design and can come in the shape of bats, baseballs, softballs etc. They add extreme value, trading power and dimension to your team's trading pins. Highly sought after at tournaments, the spinner option is an easy way to make your pin more tradeable.


No pins trade easier than those with a blinker. Blinkers add a high-tech "bling" to your Custom Trading Pins. Highly sought-after this battery powered colored lighting mechanism blinks when turned on. This option is sure to bring your custom trading pin to life like no other option we offer. Blinkers work great for eyes, and really stand out at night.



Glitter is an inexpensive way to make a sought after, highly visible and expensive looking team trading pin. Glitter is added to the enamel colors of your trading pin design. The glitter colors we use are very popular and the sparkle can really bring your design to life.


Bobbles are a second movable trading pin piece which is attached with a strong spring to the main pin. They "bobble" when the pin is moved creating an eye catching effect. This option is best for older kids as the spring can be a little more fragile than other attachments like blinkers or sliders.


Sliders are very cool and easy to trade. A second, smaller pin is attached into a channel (the "slot") on the main pin and slides up and down or side to side. Sliders are eye appealing and give a sense of action to the trading pins. Common sliders include; players running a baseline, swinging bats and moving baseballs or softballs.

Lapel Pin Plating Options

High Polished Copper
High Polished Copper
High Polished Bronze
High Polished Bronze
Antique Silver
Antique Silver
High Polished Silver
High Polished Silver
Black Nickel
Black Nickel
Antique Copper
Antique Copper
Antique Gold
Antique Gold
Black Metal
Black Metal
High Polished Gold
High Polished Gold
Antique Bronze
Antique Bronze

Custom Lapel Pin Attachment Options

We offer a variety of different optional attachments

Butterfly Clutch
Butterfly Clutch
Safety Pin
Safety Pin
Rubber Clutch
Rubber Clutch
Keychain Ring
Keychain Ring

Presentation Options

Acrylic Case
Acrylic Case
$0.25 Per Case
Velvet Box
Velvet Box
$2.25 Per Case
Included With Order
Cardstock Option
Cardstock Option

Gemstone Colors